Sunday 22 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 FORUM
Discussions by:   Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum Topics
 Search forum: 
Shimano Saint 2009
Related article
Shimano Saint 2009
Shimano unveils all-new heavy-duty (but lighter weight) "extreme" groupset

1 to 20 of 44 messages. Page: 1  2  3  To post a reply you need to be a member - Join now.
Show/hide user stats
chunky & phunky
This member’s stats are private
That gold may not be to everyones taste,bit blingtastic
Show/hide user stats
them cranks aren't as purty as my current saints IMO!
Show/hide user stats
I think the cranks look great - so does the rear mech, but £80.....
Show/hide user stats
gold, are they mad?! apart from that, it actually looks really rather nice
This member’s stats are private
Looks like good kit, shame about the intrusive graphic on the cranks imho.
Show/hide user stats

They certainly are 'striking'.

Be interesting to see how the rather complex sounding 4 pot brakes hold up in terms of reliability, sounds like a potential minefield of problems... 

Show/hide user stats
AHJ, surely it's no different from a hope m4? as that's got 2 pairs of different sized pistons?
Show/hide user stats

I was referring to how the servo wave means one set of pads hits the rotor before the other.

I dunno, maybe I don't know enough of brakes to concieve a simple way of doing it... 

Show/hide user stats
Fo' shizzle ma'nizzle. Dis Shizzlemano is jus the bling da homie need on his steed. Saint, word.
Show/hide user stats
anyhojoe - El Presidente wrote (see)

They certainly are 'striking'.

Be interesting to see how the rather complex sounding 4 pot brakes hold up in terms of reliability, sounds like a potential minefield of problems...  

I was referring to how the servo wave means one set of pads hits the rotor before the other.

I dunno, maybe I don't know enough of brakes to concieve a simple way of doing it... 



Given that Avid Codes, Hope mono 4's, Magura Gustavs and XT755's are all 4 pot brakes. There shouldn't be anything to worry about.

 The pads hitting one pair before the other is because the pistons are slightly different diameters. So the pressure increases faster in one pair than the other. This was on the old XT's as well and works fine. Its also extremely simple.

It has nothing to with the servo wave. Which is a sliding pivot in the lever, it doesn't really affect the caliper at all and we already know both systems work. Servo wave is all the way back from V-brakes after all.

Although its interesting to see Shimano go back to a two piece caliper instead of the forged one you get in xt, xtr and the current Saint. Anyone have any ideas why? 

Show/hide user stats
Jonathan Hancock wrote (see)



 The pads hitting one pair before the other is because the pistons are slightly different diameters. So the pressure increases faster in one pair than the other. This was on the old XT's as well and works fine. Its also extremely simple.

It has nothing to with the servo wave. Which is a sliding pivot in the lever, it doesn't really affect the caliper at all and we already know both systems work. Servo wave is all the way back from V-brakes after all.




Ah, explained.

Thank you kindly! 

Show/hide user stats
might've been a bit too complicated to forge a 4pot one piece caliper?

maybe they said it for stiffness reasons (like avid)
Show/hide user stats
The pressure is the same throughout the system. If one piston moves before the other it's because seal resistance is relatively higher on a smaller piston. The main thing is that the smaller leading piston counters the pistons/pads' tendancy to twist due to rotation of the disc which increases pressure on the leading edge of the pad. Snatch is reduced for the same reason and also because the twin piston design allows a longer pad. With a single piston the pad is offset on the piston towards the leading edge to counter piston twist and snatch.
Show/hide user stats

I don't think that your seal resistance reason is correct John. If I remember right from Hydraulics theory back in the day, as you have the same volume of fluid entering the 2 pistons the one with the smaller surface area has to move more to maintain the same volume as the large one, and as you said the pressures will be the same in each piston.

Show/hide user stats
Rubbish. Edit: The pistons generally move together. If there is a difference the bigger piston moves first and moves further. Try it.
Edited: 18/04/08 20:35
Show/hide user stats
We'll be back to the more pistons = more power fallacy before long Arry. Before anyone brings it up I'll remind everyone that for a given suface area of slave pisons you get the same force on the pad however many pistons you have.
Show/hide user stats
I miss Dylan.  He would have a strong opinion on a subject like this.
 

Page: 1  2  3  


Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Home > Forum > BeginnersForum jump  
Support our sponsors
 

Support our sponsors

Offers, Competitions and Promotions
win free stuff with rcuk

Squirt Competition
Win 1 of 50 bottles of SQUIRT - Long lasting Dry Lube
Ticket2RideBC Adventures
Advertorial: Ticket2RideBC specialises in guided mountain bike adventures
British Heart Foundation
Advertorial: Get cycling for the BHF and raise vital money