part of the magicalia cycling network: RoadCyclingUK : BikeMagic  
Magicalia Logo
LAPIERRE by HotlinesBIKEmagic
Why should I become a member?
  •  
  • HOME
  • GEAR
  • HOWTO
  • EVENTS
  • TRAILS
  • FORUMS
  • GALLERY
Join  
Meet the team  
RSS  
Advertise  
Blogs  
Bikes  
Brakes  
Skills and training  
Media  
Forks and shocks  
Contact points  
Accessories  
Holidays  
Drivetrain  
Wheels  
Clothing  
Trail centres  
Gear News  
Classifieds  
Forum  
Buy online  
Local shops  
Riding  
Maintenance  
Beginners forum  
Clubs and riders  
Beginners  
Kit forum  
Events calendar  
Events news  
Events features  
Trail News  
Ride reports  
Trail centres  
Holidays  
Rides forum  
New Member Introductions  
Soap Box  
Rides  
Beginners  
Maintenance  
Kit forum  
MTB  
Gallery  
Road & Touring  
Ladies only  
FORUMS
You are looking at: Home : FORUMS : Kit forum
shimano saint or raceface diabolus for freeride toy
 
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum TopicsHelp | Settings | Public Profile
 Search forum: 
shimano saint or raceface diabolus for freeride toy
which is better for 15st pie eater
1 to 4 of 4 messages
Show/hide user stats
Paul B
04/03/08 13:47
 24 forum posts 1 review

In the market for a new crank and bb as i am fed up with the clunking and loosening of the truvative huss that came on the bike ( Spec SX trail for freeride/alpine trips)

Was wondering does anyone have any strong opinions on which to buy. Raceface has 1 yr guarantee on BB and lifetime on cranks, have got xtype on my other bike and is OK.

Shimano lighter, cheaper but dont know about warranty. Also suggests to be fitted by LBS first time?

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
daftpunk
04/03/08 19:36
 2719 forum posts 3 photos 1 article 8 reviews
The RF are supposed to be practically indestructible and stiffer but the BB bearings aren't quite as long lasting as the Shimano (but both are interchangeable as far as I know). Both are good cranks for hard hitting stuff just depends on how pimpy you want to go.
 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Jimmy Jazz
04/03/08 22:47

I'd go with Saint. Tried and tested by downhillers all over the world, I don't think I've ever heard of any breaking. I've used some Diabolous stuff in the past, stems and seatposts, and they seemed a bit heavy and overbuilt. You don't really see a lot of Diabolous stuff around, it's mostly Thomson for stems and posts and Saints for cranks.

FWIW I was about to switch to XT for downhill until I changed to a bike with an 83mm BB and they wouldn't fit, plenty strong enough tho'.

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
2many gears, little idea
05/03/08 09:46
 464 forum posts 17 reviews 2 classifieds
i'd go raceface!

simply because they dont ever break, i've heard if the bearings / BB wearing..but you dont pedal under power as much on FR bike, not like XC. i have not found it an issue.
BB in my demo is 3 yrs old... it's fine. the stiffness the diabolous confers is immense.

weight is more, but does it really matter? you want solid!

keeps the big S of you bike as well, if you're so inclined.

the cost is more i accept.

both systems recommend a 1st time LBS fitting, to ensure frame edges are even.

i've fitted both myself, it's not beyond the wit of normal man.

 Send to friend

  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Forum jump  
Latest News
Yeti ASR-5 Carbon first ride - Published in Gear News
A quick spin on the all-carbon Yeti 120mm trail bike - 18/3/10
Absa Cape Epic about to kick off - Published in Event News
The countdown is on - 17/3/10
SRAM X7 launched - Published in Gear News
XX 2x10 trickles down to new X7 groupset - 17/3/10
  • Merida 2010
  • Merida Ninety Six Carbon Team-D
Shopping Partners
Chain Reaction Cycles
AW Cycles
Cycle Surgery
Sprockets.uk.com
OS Map Shop
Stif Cycles
Edinburgh Bicycle Co-op
Travel Partners
Three Peaks Bike & Hike
Explore Cycles
Endurance Life
Sierra Cycling
Bike tours in France & Italy
Facebook

Become a fan of BikeMagic

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Visit our sister site RoadCyclingUK

Click here

Meet the Team

Click here

Other Magicalia Sites

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Active

  • AVReview
  • BIKEmagic
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • RoadCyclingUK
  • Visordown

About BikeMagic

  • Join BikeMagic
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Your BikeMagic

  • RSS

Reviews

  • Mountain bikes reviews
  • Forks and shocks reviews
  • MTB Drivetrain reviews
  • MTB brakes reviews
  • MTB Contact points reviews
  • MTB Wheels reviews
  • BMX reviews
  • Accessories reviews
  • Clothing reviews
  • Media reviews
  • Holidays reviews
  • Trail centres reviews

Competitions

Rides & Holidays

  • News
  • Trail tales
  • Holidays
  • Holiday reviews
  • Clubs & riders
  • Forum

Know How

  • Training
  • Maintenance
  • Forum

Events

  • Events calendar
  • News
  • Features
  • Demo days

Home

  • Read or write user product reviews
  • Find your nearest shop

Forums

  • Main forums
  • New Member Introductions
  • Beginners
  • Maintenance
  • MTB
  • Road & Touring
  • Soap Box
  • Rides
  • Kit forum
  • Gallery
  • Ladies Only
© 1999-2010 Magicalia Ltd. Part of the Magicalia group www.magicalia.com