part of the magicalia cycling network: RoadCyclingUK : BikeMagic  
Magicalia Logo
LAPIERRE by HotlinesBIKEmagic
Why should I become a member?
  •  
  • HOME
  • GEAR
  • HOWTO
  • EVENTS
  • TRAILS
  • FORUMS
  • GALLERY
Join  
Meet the team  
RSS  
Advertise  
Blogs  
Bikes  
Brakes  
Skills and training  
Media  
Forks and shocks  
Contact points  
Accessories  
Holidays  
Drivetrain  
Wheels  
Clothing  
Trail centres  
Gear News  
Classifieds  
Forum  
Buy online  
Local shops  
Riding  
Maintenance  
Beginners forum  
Clubs and riders  
Beginners  
Kit forum  
Events calendar  
Events news  
Events features  
Trail News  
Ride reports  
Trail centres  
Holidays  
Rides forum  
New Member Introductions  
Soap Box  
Rides  
Beginners  
Maintenance  
Kit forum  
MTB  
Gallery  
Road & Touring  
Ladies only  
FORUMS
You are looking at: Home : FORUMS : Kit forum
Cracked Hollowtech Cranks
 
Latest Posts | New Discussions | Hot Threads | Forum TopicsHelp | Settings | Public Profile
 Search forum: 
Cracked Hollowtech Cranks
1 to 6 of 6 messages
This member’s stats are private
Klunk
16/10/09 08:54
wa havin at look at this over on the other side and decided to check mine out, I have cracks in both arms of my saints (can't have done more than 20 miles serious riding ! ) and what look like a crack in the drive side of my XT M770's.
 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Nobby
16/10/09 09:08

That started me worrying too but the latest post gives a solid explanation which I'm happy with.

Would be interested to hear from Madison though.... 

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
John Gourette
16/10/09 09:20
 15676 forum posts 3 photos 1 article 11 reviews 28 bookmarks
Don't worry about it.
 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
nick howell
17/10/09 22:44
 259 forum posts 2 reviews

If lots of people have the "crack" and yet no-one has reported a failure it implies that it isn't a significant problem. Stats do come in handy I find.

 Send to friend
Show/hide user stats
Mike! :¬)
17/10/09 23:24
 15526 forum posts 1 photo 7 articles 14 reviews 10 bookmarks 1 classified
If the cranks are hollow, could it not just be where they're crimped?

I can't be arsed to have a look at the latest post or my own cranks...
 Send to friend
This member’s stats are private
Mister Bump
17/10/09 23:32

Taken from the STW thread - 

 Hi everyone, Albert from Madison here.

Understandably some of you are concerned about what might appear to be cracks at the tips of your crankarms just below the pedal inserts.

This was brought to Shimano's attention some time ago and upon further investigation they were identified as forging marks (Stato's hit the nail on the head with his explaination). This is why so many of you will have discovered them upon further investigation.

Rest assured these marks do not in any way affect the performance or durability of the cranks/chainsets and to date no cranks have been returned to us with actual cracks at the end of the crank arm.

Thanks
Albert
(Madison)

 Send to friend

  
 

Change stats view
Make external bookmarkAdd to My Bookmarks

« Previous thread   -   Next thread »
Forum jump  
Latest News
DT Swiss launch new forks - Published in Gear News
A quick first look at the new forks from DT Swiss - 11/3/10
Atherton Racing Commencal MaxMax - Published in Gear News
New limited edition jump bike released - 9/3/10
CelticXtreme 2010 - Published in Event News
Six-day mountain bike stage race in Ireland - 8/3/10
  • Ragley TD-1 29er launched
  • British Mountain Bike Demo Series
Shopping Partners
Stif Cycles
Kudu Bikes
Chain Reaction Cycles
AW Cycles
Sprockets.uk.com
Edinburgh Bicycle Co-op
Cycle Surgery
OS Map Shop
Travel Partners
Three Peaks Bike & Hike
Sierra Cycling
Endurance Life
Explore Cycles
Bike tours in France & Italy
Facebook

Become a fan of BikeMagic

Twitter

Follow us on twitter

Visit our sister site RoadCyclingUK

Click here

Meet the Team

Click here

Other Magicalia Sites

Parenting

  • Junior
  • Practical Parenting
  • ThinkBaby
  • MadeForMums

Active

  • AVReview
  • BIKEmagic
  • GOLFmagic
  • OUTDOORSmagic
  • RoadCyclingUK
  • Visordown

About BikeMagic

  • Join BikeMagic
  • About us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & conditions
  • Support
  • Advertise with us

Your BikeMagic

  • RSS

Reviews

  • Mountain bikes reviews
  • Forks and shocks reviews
  • MTB Drivetrain reviews
  • MTB brakes reviews
  • MTB Contact points reviews
  • MTB Wheels reviews
  • BMX reviews
  • Accessories reviews
  • Clothing reviews
  • Media reviews
  • Holidays reviews
  • Trail centres reviews

Competitions

Rides & Holidays

  • News
  • Trail tales
  • Holidays
  • Holiday reviews
  • Clubs & riders
  • Forum

Know How

  • Training
  • Maintenance
  • Forum

Events

  • Events calendar
  • News
  • Features
  • Demo days

Home

  • Read or write user product reviews
  • Find your nearest shop

Forums

  • Main forums
  • New Member Introductions
  • Beginners
  • Maintenance
  • MTB
  • Road & Touring
  • Soap Box
  • Rides
  • Kit forum
  • Gallery
  • Ladies Only
© 1999-2010 Magicalia Ltd. Part of the Magicalia group www.magicalia.com