I've both a Gore overshoe and Altura, both with abrasion resistant soles.

Bollox they abraid just by walking a couple of strides to get on your bike.

I'd look for something with a very good rubberised sole.

Quinny, I have about three pairs of overshoes, lying around, hardly used. I have some of those alturas with reflective piping.

PM me if you're interested, I will let them go for a a fistful of dollars.

The Endura MTB ones work well, kept me dry and warm today.

Although winter boots would be better.

I used Specialized Taho shoes for years and the toe of the overshoe constantly lifted off. Even large quantities of gaffa tape would only keep it in place for an hour or two. Last year i switched to Shimano shoes and the Endura MT500s fit perfectly with no annoying 'toe lift'.

Trainer type shoes and overshoes just don't mix well IME