Home > Members > My Reviews
Monday 23 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 the messiah

Latest Reviews

1 to 10 of 18 reviews.Page: 1  2  
Manitou Sherman Breakout Plus 
Posted: 06/09/04
Updated: 27/06/07
'TAKING MOUNTAINBIKES TO THE NEXT LEVEL!'
Strengths:
A 170mm travel fork that can get round tight switchbacks!
Stiffer than the Marzocchi Super-T's I used to run.
Tuning that works, a lockdown to 150mm for climbing that works.
A 20mm thru. axle system that isn't "that" hard to use.
Super smooth action and lovely feeling to the damping. Only ever bottomed them on very silly drops (Morzine/Les Gets).
Light enough to be peddled back up a hill (Scotland), and make my big Nicolai suitable for all my mountainbiking needs.
Weaknesses:
Availability if 1point5 frames - not really the forks fault. Manufacturers should embrace this engineering solution to a weakness in mountainbike design (extreme use mountainbikes - not racing whippetry).
Having to get a frame made to take the forks, or compromise on the frame you want.
Price? Still cheaper than most triple clamps though.
Overall:
1point5 has made for an advancement in the design of mountainbikes. It's a shame more manufacturers haven't woken up to this new standard.
I used to run tripple clamps but I hated the effect of the lock when nogotiating technical terrain, and the scars on my knees from the top clamps. But with 1point5 and these Manitou Breakout Plus forks I am a happy camper.
Manitou deserve to do well with this awesome fork which feels far better than boxxers etc straight out of the box - it's just a shame more manufacturers haven't woken up to it.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
Jericho 33t Suffering 
Posted: 27/03/03
'A betootifull single chainring that has 33 teeth.'
Strengths:
The 33 tooth is cool as it means I don't really need a tensioner on my singlespeed project Kona Explosif (33:18).
Looks totaly awesome in that wonderfull-different-expensive-custom-groovy kind of way.
A use for those olde LX/XT/XTR cranks that have been kicking around because all the rings are worn and it's cheaper to buy a new chainset.
Perfect chain alignment on my bike.
Shiney thing from a little manufacturer - gotta love'm!
Weaknesses:
You need an old chainset with the splined connection to butcher.
Special tool needed to remove the spider from the cranks.
Only available from the goode-old-U-S-of-A.
May need a spacer for some cranks - same spacer as between the sprockets on a cassette luckily enough.
It cost money - but what doesn't.
Overall:
Excellent answer to a question or problem you didn't need to ask or have solved.

But a great product which does what it set out to do - and makes me smile when I look down at it - suffering on the climbs!
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
60%
Overall Rating
 
87%
 
FSA Power Pro MTB Cranks only 
Posted: 18/12/01
'NOT VERY IMPRESIVE.'
Strengths:
They have 5 hole's on the spider bit to hold a chainring, have threaded hole's in the ends for pedals and the square taper bit in the middle fits onto a bottom bracket.
Works well in the Kitchen/Garage/Shed etc.
Weaknesses:
I was using it for my fully rigid singlespeed cross cuntree bike (No 6 or 7ft drops here boys - just good old fashioned XC riding).
2 rides and the square taper is no longer square. I tightened them after the first ride but this still happenned.
Can't say they felt more or less flexy than the XT cranks I took off.
Overall:
As long as I get my £25 back I'll be happy.
Other than that these really are pretty weak cranks - but what did I expect for £25.

I should have known better.
 
Performance
 
20%
Reliability
 
20%
Value
 
20%
Overall Rating
 
20%
 
Shimano UN72 Bottom Bracket - Tapered 
Posted: 14/12/01
'A FINE BOTTOM BRACKET'
Strengths:
Cheap and reliable. Cheaper BB's last significantly less time.
Weaknesses:
Lasts as long as it lasts - then throw it away.
Overall:
Does the job.
Makes it hard to justify spending anymore.
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
80%
Overall Rating
 
80%
 
Shimano Deore XT 
Posted: 14/12/01
'GOOD SOLID CRANKS.'
Strengths:
Excellent shifting performance.
Strong enough for most riding.
Square fit taper fits any bottom bracket.
Can be found quite cheap if you hunt around.
Not flexy - or not as you'd notice anyway.
Look alright, not posey though.
Don't scratch up to bad.
Strong for the price (other cold forged cranks are twice the price).
Weaknesses:
Rings don't last that well - but none do.
Inner rings are alloy and hence wear really badly.
It's shimano so it looks boring.
Overall:
A very good crank for the money. Probably the best crank for the money, but not the "coolest".
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
80%
Overall Rating
 
80%
 
RideOn Ultralight GoreTex Gear Cables 
Posted: 12/12/01
'THEY CHANGE GEARS ON MY BIKES.'
Strengths:
Last for years.
Unafected by all the mud and stuff.
Cheap - in the long run.
Front mech cables - 3 years on one bike, 2 on an another (both still going)
Rear Mech cables - 2 years and counting on one bike, and I get about 18 months on my full susser.
Weaknesses:
Awkward to set up.
Not so good on full suss bikes or where the cables see a lot of motion (but still as good if not better than normal cables - except XTR)
Expensive - but economic.
Overall:
Brilliant.
I get about a month from cheap cables. 6 months to a year from XTR but these puppies last for years.

(not the superlite versions - just the normal ones)

I like them.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
Kona Explosif Steel 
Posted: 12/12/01
'ON IT'S THIRD LIFE - IT'S NOT BROKEN YET.'
Strengths:
This bike keeps on going.
It's a 1995 Columbus Max Explosif Frame.
I dented the top tube within two weeks of buying it. I spent the next 4 years trying to bend other bits of it.
Rides like a wet dream with rigid forks.
Weaknesses:
No disk mount - where disks about 7 years ago?
Became a "ditch magnet" with suspension forks.
I can't seem to break it.
Overall:
I tried so hard to break this but it still lives.
First I raced it XC.
Then I toured and did full mountain day rides.
Raced it downhill a few times.
Spent a year in a shed.
Currently built as a singlespeed.

I'd love to replace it with something fancier but it keeps on trucking.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
FSA Orbit Xtreme Headset 
Posted: 22/05/01
'Best headset for the money'
Strengths:
These headsets have been outlasting my frames for years.
Easy to change forks due to the split lower race thingy.
Weaknesses:
Not yet!
Perhaps not fashionable enough - ie, it's £40-50 for a no name brand.
Overall:
Fit and forget headset that can take a beating without even needing to be looked at.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
Panaracer Fire DH Tyre 
Posted: 15/05/01
'Awesome Cross-Cuntree tyre.'
Strengths:
Awesome grip on the climbs and descents.
Lasts pretty well and is gripy to the end.
Good in the wet and dry.
Puncture resistance is good unless you ride through a very thorny bush in Spain.
Weaknesses:
The thorny thing - but never in the UK
Weight - it's a whole Kilo!!! (Each!!!)
You need wide rims or the tyres "roll".
Oh yeah - £35 each is hubhubhubhub a bit steep.
Overall:
I realy like these tyres - so much that I bought another set. The puncture thing was realy bad but the thorns were huge etc etc yawn.

I use these for Cross Country but they were designed for Doonhall. They are heavy but I will live with that for the grip and the pinch flat protection.
Big forks, big travel, big tyres - I love Mountain Biking.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
60%
Overall Rating
 
80%
 
Selle Italia Flite Genuine Gel 
Posted: 04/05/01
'Contact between shorts and bike'
Strengths:
Very comfy for the long haul. I still get a bit numb on the really huge rides. But for a run of up to 4 hrs or so this is fine.
Lots of kevlar bits and the leather seems of better quality than normaln flite's.
Weaknesses:
If it suits you.
I love flites.
The rails eventualy bend up to the shell which flexes out into your thighs. The saddle becomes uncomfortable but this happens after about 3 years but by then the whole thing is pretty shabby anyway.
Overall:
Keeps my @rse happy!
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
 
 
 
See entire review section
Support our sponsors
 

Support our sponsors