Saturday 4 July 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 GEAR NEWS 11 / 07 / 07
 

2008 Deore XT: First riding impressions

shimano08_xtfirst_crank_lo (16K) shimano08_xtfirst_controlsl (13K) shimano08_xtfirst_mech_lo (10K) shimano08_xtfirst_brake_lo (8K)

We brought you an early look at Shimano's all-new 2008 Deore XT groupset a while ago (part 1, part 2). Since then we've been to some bike launches and had a chance to get some riding time in on the new parts - expect to see a lot of XT on 2008 bikes.

We'll start with the things that don't really feel any different from the saddle. Perhaps slightly surprisingly, the new XT cranks stick with the twin pinch-bolt arrangement for the non-drive side arm rather than the new XTR style of an axial bolt and bearing preload doofer. The arms are a new shape, which most people (us included) find a little disappointing in terms of appearance - the current cranks are quite distinctive, but the '08 ones, well, aren't. Durability should be improved, though, especially with the introduction of a steel/carbon fibre middle ring instead of the old aluminium one. It'll come as no surprise to hear that the front shifting is swift and snappy.

The innovative stuff is elsewhere. The big news is the rear Shadow derailleur, with a low-profile design that not only promises a number of benefits but looks likely to deliver. Once you see one actually mounted on a bike it makes a great deal of sense. The fixed part of the mech lies entirely inside the end of the QR nut, so is less likely to get bashed if you fall over. In most gears, the front end of the parallelogram is inside the nut too, but even when it isn't, that's the bit that moves in and out - hit it and it should just swing out of the way.

Also very welcome is the more direct cable routing. Rather than the big loop of housing of old, the Shadow design uses a short, straight length (along very similar lines to SRAM's mechs, only without making a turn around a cam on the mech itself). The whole thing looks very clean, and works a treat (although we had to do a bit of fiddling, what with manufacturer's launch bikes often being assembled in a bit of a hurry...).

Driving the mechs are new shifter pods. They're along very similar lines to the already-popular XTR ones, but don't have the Multi-Release feature that lets you shift multiple gears in both directions. You get a bi-directional trigger that you can operate with finger or thumb, but the current shifters have that too. The new ones are much neater-looking and are just fine in use, but expect to see a fair few bikes getting an upspec to the XTR units to get Multi-Release. We didn't particularly miss it ourselves, but then we haven't really managed to get the hang of not getting two gears at once on XTR when using our thumbs to upshift.

Finally we have the brakes, and this is the other place where XT gets the innovation. The calipers are very XTR-esque, and the levers are clearly also closely related. But the XT levers incorporate Servo-Wave - a variable leverage ratio through the lever stroke. From rest, moving the lever a small amount drives the pads a long way, allowing them to sit further from the rotor to reduce drag. Once they've reached the rotor, a cam in the lever gears up the action to move the pads less for a given lever movement to increase power.

The system also incorporates what Shimano calls "free stroke adjustment", altering how much lever travel there is before any actual braking occurs. Combined with the usual reach adjustment you should be able to get the feel that you want. The brakes take a little getting used to, though. Initially there's a sense of nothing happening for ages and then all the braking at once, but once you get the feel of it they're really rather good. Shimano claims a 20% power increase, but the most obvious difference to us is how much quieter they run in grotty conditions. That little bit of extra pad clearance certainly seems to pay dividends.

So first impressions are good. The big question, of course, is how well all this stuff's going to last. A big box of XT stuff is winging its way BM-wards right now, so we'll keep you posted...


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 26 messages, read more:
X Commie 
Posted: 11/07/07 14:48:02 02
The cranks do look outrageously bland.

I like the brakes and mech though.
Read more...
Read member reviews:
Chainsets (349 products)
Disc Brakes (273 products)
Rear Mechs (62 products)
Shifters (147 products)
Related articles:
All-new Shimano Deore unveiled
OK, not completely new - the chain and cassettes are the same. The rest of the workhorse groupset gets a thorough grooming, though
Shimano SLX
Some months in on Shimano's new mid-range contender - here's the lowdown
Shimano XT M776 wheelset
20mm front hub, wide rims, funky graphics - XT's all-mountain wheels tested
Tektro Auriga Pro disc brakes
Tektro expand their range with new hydraulic stoppers
Shimano SLX: First look
Yes, it's 2009 already. Shimano repositions LX, drops Hone and replaces both with the all-new SLX mid-range group - and here it is
Shimano recalls gloves
PRO, Shimano and Saint cycling gloves in voluntary recall
Shimano M300 Custom-Fit shoes
A few months on from having Shimano's latest shoes sucked on to our feet - how are we getting on?
XTR Shadow mech revealed
Shimano's low-profile derailleur technology appears in top-end carbon fibre configuration
Shimano Deore XT revealed: Part 2
Chainset, brakes, hubs, pedals and wheels from the 25th anniversary XT group
Shimano Deore XT revealed: Part 1
25th anniversary of Shimano's workhorse groupset and a whole new bunch of parts to celebrate. First up, the transmission components

Support our sponsors
 

Support our sponsors

Offers, Competitions and Promotions
win

Win Win a return travel voucher
For two adults and two bicycles courtesy of Brittany Ferries

The IOW Cycling Festival
Advertorial: The Isle of Wight Cycling Festival 19 - 27 September 2009
Ford S-MAX
Advertorial: Be Inspired With The Versatile Ford S-MAX
Ticket2RideBC Adventures
Advertorial: Ticket2RideBC specialises in guided mountain bike adventures
British Heart Foundation
Advertorial: Get cycling for the BHF and raise vital money