Saturday 21 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 BM REVIEWS 20 / 03 / 09
 

Magura Thor

magura09_thortest_l (36K)

The addition of the Thor to Magura's fork line-up fills an obvious gap between the German brand's 130mm QR-axled forks like the Menja and the mighty 160mm through-axle Wotan. At 140mm of travel, with a Maxle 20mm through-axle but under 2kg on the scales, it looks like a strong competitor for the likes of RockShox's 2009 Revelation or Fox's QR15 forks.

At a whisker under 4lb the Thor is a decent weight for what it is - it's a whole pound lighter than the RockShox Pike we took off, and that's down to more than the Pike's coil spring. Starting at the top, we have the usual (but quite slimline) 6082-T6 forged aluminium crown holding 32mm stanchions. The lowers use Magura's distinctive Dual Arch Design which does what it says on the tin - a pair of arches, one front and one rear. Whether the touted stiffness benefits are real or not, it's a feature that certainly stands out.

At the bottom end the Thor follows the lead of its bigger brother Wotan with SRAM's Maxle quick-release through-axle setup, although it gets the newer, slightly more user-friendly Maxle 360 axle. There's also an interesting option in the shape of a single pinch bolt on the right-hand leg. If you like, you can ditch the Maxle, fit Magura's own through-axle and use the pinch bolt to hold it in place. You lose the convenience of a quick release, but you also lose 60g. Your call. The left leg has a post-mount for the brake. It's worth noting that it's a 180mm mount - bolt a PM caliper straight to it and it'll be aligned for a 180mm rotor. That means that you can't run a 160, but the fork is capable of taking up to 210.

Inside there's an air spring in the left leg and oil damping in the right. The Thor uses the same Flight Control Remote travel adjust system as the Wotan. Push the lever, compress the fork and release the lever and the Thor sits at 100mm travel - short enough to deliver useful uphill weight distribution/steeper head angle benefits but not so short that your pedals bounce off the trail. To reextend the fork you need to push the lever and unweight the front wheel, which is as good an excuse as any to brush up on your wheelie skills.

The right-hand leg has a rebound damping dial at the bottom and the Albert Select+ platform/compression damping dial at the top. This has two parts. The blue outer dial turns the damping circuit on or off, while the inner gold knob sets how firm it is, from "not very" to "pretty much locked out". If there's any room left on your handlebars there's an optional remote lever to drive the Albert Select too.

Setup ought to be straightforward, with just one air valve, a rebound dial and the Albert Select compression damping that you initially just turn off. There's a table of air pressures for rider weights on the fork leg and everything - what could possibly go wrong? Well, it turns out to be fiddlier than it ought to be. For a start, the numbers on the fork leg seem to us to be substantially too small - try them and you're on the bumpers at the first glimpse of a pebble. Use sag and trial and error as your guide, though, and you can find the sweet spot, although it's very much a "spot" - we found that the Thor offered quite a small air pressure window in which ideal performance was to be found.

Also complicating matters is the self-charging negative air spring and the Flight Control Remote travel lockdown. To ensure that the negative air chamber gets enough pressure, you need to occasionally press the FCR bar lever (or, if you've, um, managed to snap that off in a crash, turn the dial atop the left fork leg) while inflating the fork. And if you need to let air out, you need to activate the FCR (without actually compressing the fork) while so doing, otherwise only the positive air chamber loses pressure.

Once you've got it sorted, though (write the pressure down when you've found it...), the Thor fair rips. Despite the low weight, you're not giving up anything in stiffness, and the action is very smooth indeed. You really do need to watch that air pressure, though - a little low and all the travel runs away, a little high and it sits up too much. Obviously the same is true of all air forks, but the Thor seems particularly sensitive to it.

Our only other performance niggle is that our sample fork has a slight top-out knock. It's lessened considerably by following the lever-pushing recommendations in the manual but has never gone away entirely. That said, we've ridden more recent units that haven't done it at all, and it doesn't affect performance beyond psychologically. The lockdown is pretty useful (although on the other hand, since that mishap with the bar lever we haven't actually missed having it). It's certainly holding up well - we've been running this one for six months with no other issues.

Ups and downs

good Great performance once set up, stiff yet light, useful travel lockdown

bad Finicky setup, can be a little "toppy"

Verdict

Value for money is, as with most bike parts at the moment, a tricky one to assess. On the one hand, £600 is clearly a large amount of money for a fork. On the other, it's no more than what comparable forks from other manufacturers will cost you. Despite the simplicity of its adjustments, the Thor takes time to set up, but once its there it's a match for anything. And it looks great.

Ratings

Performance
Value
Overall

Our ratings explained >>


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 1 messages, read more:
Chris Lupton 
Posted: 24/03/09 12:25:54 54
I recently sent my Thors back to Magura UK and they replaced the Flight Control unit, which removed the top-out clunk.
Read more...
Read member reviews:
Suspension forks (567 products)
Magura Thor
Related articles:
Magura 2010
2010 gear Raft of refinements for German forks and brakes
Magura Marta SL brakes
Lightweight German stoppers tested
Magura recalls Durin Race forks
Early production batch of 2008 Durin Race forks recalled due to possible brake arch failure
Magura 2009: First riding impressions
We've had a couple of days on the new Thor 140mm all-mountain fork - here's the lowdown
Magura 2009
A few more details of the German manufacturer's forthcoming shocks, forks and brakes
Magura Wotan
Magura's all-mountain/freeride 160/120mm dual-arch fork tested
Magura Menja
Magura's AM/XC 100mm air sprung mid-range fork tested

Support our sponsors

Support our sponsors

Offers, Competitions and Promotions
win

Win a Lumicycle LED4 system
Worth £329

Ticket2RideBC Adventures
Advertorial: Ticket2RideBC specialises in guided mountain bike adventures
British Heart Foundation
Advertorial: Get cycling for the BHF and raise vital money