Sunday 22 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 BM REVIEWS 22 / 05 / 09
 

Mountain Bike Guide Dorset

mtb_guide_dorset (27K)

Ernest Press is a long-standing producer of MTB route guides, being the home of almost legendary titles like Jeremy Ashcroft's Mountain Bike Guide to The Lake District, The Howgills and the Yorkshire Dales, which is not only still in print but also still has 23in MTBs with bullmoose bars and top tube pads on the cover.

The slightly retro ethos runs through Ernest Press's more recent guides too, like Mountain Bike Guide Dorset, written by local rider Colin Dennis. Dorset isn't high on the list of usual MTB suspects, but it's got a fair bit to offer. Half of it is classified as an Area of Outstanding Natural Beauty and there's a healthy network of rights of way.

The guide contains details of 33 routes, covering the whole county (which is divided into North, South, East and West within the book). Several of the routes have overlaps and can thus be easily combined into longer rides - these are clearly indicated in the text.

Each route is classified as Easy, Moderate or Hard. They're inevitably slightly subjective and may well vary with conditions - until you've tried a couple you won't really know how you compare with the author. Unfortunately the contents pages only list the routes by location, and the overview map doesn't give any indication of grading, so if you want to quickly home in on, say, the Moderate routes you're out of luck.

Every description gives a distance, the grading, which maps you'll need, local facilities, a brief description of the prevailing terrain and a short introduction before the step-by-step directions. You'll want to spend some time with the book and the appropriate OS map to figure out where the route goes on the map. The directions are well-served with grid references and the sketch maps have enough information to plot the route out on a real map. There's not much else on them, though - you get junctions, major landmarks and numbers that reference the step-by-step directions, but that's about it. There's something to be said for simplicity, but we've got used to more comprehensive (or, ideally, actual OS) maps in guide books.

We've never come across a guide book that's completely typo-free, and this one's no exception. The author also displays a distracting fondness for exclamation marks, but we can hardly criticise the text for lacking enthusiasm.

Ups and downs

good Decent selection of routes in an often-overlooked part of the country, good value

bad A little bit "old school" compared to rival offerings

Verdict

MBG Dorset is a route guide in the traditional vein, and while the likes of Vertebrate and Bikefax may have raised the game somewhat in recent times, there's something to be said for the simple approach. Particularly since MBG Dorset is 50% cheaper than its glossier rivals...

Ratings

Performance
Value
Overall

Our ratings explained >>


Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
 

Discuss this article, 1 of 3 messages, read more:
Tony Holmes 2 
Posted: 01/06/09 06:03:11 11

As a relative beginner this book gives a good starting point and from there on it is down to you to establish and build your own routes.

The book is easy to follow but some small very important details have been left out which could make some of the routes less confusing but that's part of the fun.

The gradings like in every book vary depending on the author and the conditions.

Overall this publication is varied and gives choices and a good starting point.

Read more...
Read member reviews:
Books (155 products)
Related articles:
Mountain Biking Trail Centres: The Guide
Vertebrate Publishing takes a step away from the usual guide book fare
South East Mountain Biking Ridgeway and Chilterns
Latest title in the Vertebrate Publishing guidebook roster
Rough Ride Guide launches new compact guide books
Bikemagic readers get discounts on new A5-size loose-leaf route guides
New guide to South West launched
Rough Ride Guides' second ring-binder format guidebook out now!
Bikefax launches new guide to Scottish trails
New guidebook covers natural and 7stanes trails in Southern Scotland
Beyond Hamsterley
Neil Gander's loose-leaf NE route binder package reviewed
Rough Ride Guide: South East
New MTB route guide in handy loose-leaf format, complete with comprehensive extra sections
Bike-Fax: Snowdonia
Bike-Fax's first MTB route guide reviewed, in all its bilingual glory
South West Mountain Biking
The second of Vertebrate Graphics's MTB guidebooks reviewed
The Trailrider Guide to Spain
Ambitious route guide for a whole country reviewed

Support our sponsors

Support our sponsors

Offers, Competitions and Promotions
win

Win a Lumicycle LED4 system
Worth £329

Ticket2RideBC Adventures
Advertorial: Ticket2RideBC specialises in guided mountain bike adventures
British Heart Foundation
Advertorial: Get cycling for the BHF and raise vital money