Home > Product Reviews > Disc Brakes > Magura Julie Disc Brake Reviews
Sunday 22 November 2009 | Personalise | Help  
 Magura Julie Disc Brake
Summary|Reviews|Discussions|Start a discussion
Bookmark this
Magura Julie Disc Brake
More about Magura
Average Rating: 4 out of 5
No. of Reviews: 11
RRP: £79.99
Year: 2004

Description: Fully hydraulic disc brakes. Open two pot system. 180mm front 160mm rear discs. Mineral oil filled

 REVIEWS
 
1 to 10 of 11 reviews, to post a review you need to be a member - Join now.Page: 1  2  
LES STEEL 
Posted: 17/01/03
'UNBEATABLE FOR THE PRICE'
Strengths:
TOTALLY RELIABLE WITH A FIVE YEAR LEAK PROOF WARRANTY. NO SQUEAKS,SQUEALS OR RATTLES.
Weaknesses:
COMPOSITE (i.e. PLASTIC ) MASTER CYLINDER HOUSINS SLIGHTLY FLEXES BUT UNNOTICEABLE IN NORMAL USE.
Overall:
SEEN THEM FOR £55 PER END BY MAIL ORDER, EVEN AT £75 I CAN'T FAULT THEM. CHEAPER THAN A SET OF QUALITY V-BRAKES BUT MORE RELIABLE. BUY THEM
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
93%
 
Ben Mullard 
Posted: 24/04/03
'GREAT PRICE GREAT STOPPING'
Strengths:
Doesnt squel and has stopping power like I have ever seen. Its great.
Weaknesses:
Mine came with a plastic lever
Overall:
The stopping power is imense and for the money its unbeatable.They look good and perform well in all weather.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
93%
 
stuart carrington 
Posted: 12/06/03
'EFFECTIVE AND CHEAP'
Strengths:
No squeal, no rubbing and they work consistantly.
Weaknesses:
They progress smoothly but do reach a point where it feels as if they have suddenly locked solid. Also they can't work miracles and I've had a few scary moments when they haven't slowed me down as quickly as I would have liked - I'm 19 stone and at anything over 35 mph they don't cope too well - that said they cope better than anything else I've ever used.
Overall:
Very pleased - even if they did cost me £84.95 each; but for that my LBS fitted them as well.
 
Performance
 
60%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
80%
Overall Rating
 
73%
 
Pete Burrell 
Posted: 28/02/04
'CHEAP AND BRILLIANT'
Strengths:
good stopping power,

wavy rotors!
Weaknesses:
like the other reviewers, dont really reach a lock out point. this is good for feathering tho, and wheelies etc work better.
Overall:
extremely well priced bit of kit, and work very well. no squeeks, and virtually rub free.
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
93%
 
Russell Morgan 
Posted: 14/06/04
'GOOD VALUE - WORK WELL'
Strengths:
Very little squealinging, good solid progressive braking feel, pads have lasted well. Havn't leaked yet.
Weaknesses:
A little bit heavy, adjusting (old non-hayes mount model) is a pain. Not stick in your spokes stopping power like new hope minis.
Overall:
I like these brakes, they work very well if not brilliantly and don't seem to squeal all the time like a lot of other disc brakes I've used. If want dependable braking that won't amaze you these are for you.
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
80%
Overall Rating
 
80%
 
Tim Monger-Godfrey 
Posted: 18/06/04
'VERY GOOD INDEEL'
Strengths:
Good stopping power.
Modulation.
Looks.
Weaknesses:
None really.
Overall:
I was slightly doubtful about these, after mixed reviews, but I didn't want to cough up the 'very' extra cash for hopes.

Merlin Cycles offered a great deal including wheels, and I am not dissapointed at all. I cannot compare to others, as I have only used these discs, but it was a very worthwhile upgrade from v's.

They look nice, and are veryy efficient, with no squeal at all! Modulation is spot on, and you feel much more secure than with v's.
 
Performance
 
100%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
100%
 
Steve Madden 
Posted: 12/08/04
'PANTS'
Strengths:
None
Weaknesses:
Squeal like crazy, no power in the front, the rear shouts and vibrates really badly.
Overall:
I had the origional Julies on my old Cannondale SV700 which did nothing but leak. i thought these may be better but no, Maguras hate me. Will be swapping to Shimano Deores ASAP
 
Performance
 
40%
Reliability
 
40%
Value
 
80%
Overall Rating
 
53%
 
Richard Gill 
Posted: 19/08/04
'GREAT FOR THE PRICE'
Strengths:
Reliable, Strong, effective
Weaknesses:
Braking feels quite wooden when used very sharply
Overall:
Great Brake for it cheap price. I have used it for a couple months and it can handle anything but it does get excessively hot after constant braking
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
93%
 
Martin Barnett 
Posted: 08/10/04
'SPOT ON ME JULIE'S'
Strengths:
Price, Easy installation, They offer large brake power when needed. No squeak, squeal or rattle nothing but good braking.
Weaknesses:
You will go faster because you know you can stop better. When you crash it will hurt more!
Overall:
If you have V's get some of these! Put your V's on the misses bike.

Braided tube for rear brake is nice but okay without.
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
100%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
93%
 
Max Warren 
Posted: 18/10/04
'VERY GOOD FOR THE MONEY'
Strengths:
Good power and modulation from 180mm front rotor 160mm is more than enough for the rear. Also fairly easy to set up as they come assembled and bled and use hayes to IS adapters. Come with very nice looking wavy rotors.
Weaknesses:
A little chunky. Maybe not for beefcakes or down hillers
Overall:
I bought a pair of these from Chain Reaction Cycles for £120 after considering shimano M525’s and 4 pot XT. This my initial review. I shall update if I have any problems

For the money I can’t really fault these brakes. The power and modulation are good and there is no hint of grab. This might account for the “wooden” feeling that some people describe, but I prefer this to any sudden increase in braking like with Hayes Discs. The power is plentiful for XC and will lock both ends in most conditions, I run out of grip before stop. The power is also the same in wet conditions, which is where the modulation really helps.

The one thing that needs care is the set up of the brakes. They need to be bedded in carefully. I used a long steep tarmac road to this. You need to stop from about 25mph hard at least 30 times. Once you have done this they don’t squeal or drag. Before this they feel horrid and squeal when wet.

The lever bodies are composite (fancy plastic) and although this is initially slightly off putting they seem plenty strong enough. There is a little bit of flex in the lever bodies but you will not notice this on the trail, and my SD-5 levers on my other bike flex just as much.

Overall if you are getting your first set of disks and panic at the thought of spending £100 a brake on Hopes or Hayes, or are just on a budget these are for you.

Just pay close attention to the installation instructions in the manual !
 
Performance
 
80%
Reliability
 
80%
Value
 
100%
Overall Rating
 
87%
 
 
 
 
 MY REVIEW
 
You need to be a member to post a review. You can join here free.
Support our sponsors
 
Join BikeMagic login to BikeMagic
Forgotten your password? | Why should I join BikeMagic?

Support our sponsors

Shopping Partners
Cycle Surgery
Wiggle
Chain Reaction Cycles
Sprockets.uk.com
AW Cycles
Kudu Bikes
 
United Kingdom
Three Peaks Bike & Hike
Bike tours in France & Italy
Explore Cycles
Endurance Life
 
Offers, Competitions and Promotions
win free stuff with rcuk

Squirt Competition
Win 1 of 50 bottles of SQUIRT - Long lasting Dry Lube
Ticket2RideBC Adventures
Advertorial: Ticket2RideBC specialises in guided mountain bike adventures
British Heart Foundation
Advertorial: Get cycling for the BHF and raise vital money