Riding
You are looking at: Home : Riding

Can cycle computers slow you down?

New research suggest computers can hinder performance


Posted: 22 December 2008
by David Arthur

Most of us probably ride with some cycle computer of sorts. But it could be holding back, according to a recent study by the British Psychological Society.

Dr Dominic Micklewright of the University of Essex recently published his findings of new research into whether cyclists’ perception of time, distance and exertion levels could be influenced by cycle computers.

Working with a group of 29 serious amateur cyclists in South Africa (which seems a long way to go, we'd have thought that Essex could muster 29 serious amateur cyclists), the psychologists tested them over a series of 20km time trials under different conditions, with the riders split into three groups. One group received no feedback, one group received true speed and distance feedback, and the final group received speed and distance information that was 5% faster and further than their actual performance.

During a later "blind" (no computers) 20km time trial, cyclists from all of the groups were asked to rate their level of exertion at the moments when they believed they had cycled 4, 8, 12 and 16km. The cyclists who were conditioned without feedback had the most accurate perceptions of how far they had travelled. In contrast, the cyclists who were conditioned using either accurate or false feedback tended to underestimate how far they had cycled.

“We have been very interested to see the results which imply that over reliance on cycle computers during training can impair cyclists’ natural judgements of distance,” says Dr Micklewright. “Potentially, this could cause cyclists to under-perform during a time trial because, even when using a cycle computer, their impaired ability to perceive distance might lead them to adopt an unnecessarily conservative pacing strategy.

“Of course, the cycle computer is an essential tool for the time trial cyclist but the information they provide will only be advantageous if it has a meaningful context. Perhaps even some of the great cyclists might benefit from fine-tuning their own perceptions of distance by occasionally training without a cycle computer”.

So there you go. Knowing how fast you're going makes you slower, and ignorance really is bliss...


Previous article Previous article:
Win an Element handlebar
Next article:Next article
Cannondale Factory Racing 2009

Discuss this story

How can I get funding to run a study like this? I'd like to research the possibility that using chamois cream has a negative impact on performance by being very distracting.

Think I can get someone to stump up the cash?

When I saw the headline I did think it was going to be something about wheel magnets adding 0.000028% resistance to a wheels rotation, there's another potential goldmi... *ahem* study!


Posted: 22/12/2008 10:51

Being a fat porker will.
Posted: 22/12/2008 12:15

Besides which think of all those batteries slowly going flat before being recycled in some poisonous factory in China.

I you believe a computer slows you down think what a heart rate monitor can do.

Junk, bin it when the battery goes flat.


Posted: 22/12/2008 12:45

Heart rate monitors often make for depressing reading.


Posted: 22/12/2008 12:49

My Garmin has a training buddy on it, it makes me ride much harder and faster.
Posted: 22/12/2008 15:27

Me too - problem is I'm struggling to stay with the bastard at the minute  
Posted: 22/12/2008 15:31

I hope for accuracy's sake this was a double blind experiment.

Then again I suppose they would all crash.


Posted: 23/12/2008 09:24

I totally believe that cycle computers DO SLOW YOU DOWN. Pissing around with them at the ranch, having to tune them, defibrilate them, calibrate them or whatever - even go back for the bastards when they fall off all slows you down. I hate technology when I am in nature and hate that my friend loves it (you know who you are Bazza!!!). The cake goes to you Richard G though for checking your text messages half way down a downhill run.

Long may your plastic bits burn in Brechfa.

Si


Posted: 28/12/2008 23:54

I remember a letter in MBUK about 7-8 years ago that was about exactly that, the amount of deflection caused by a wheel magnet/computer. It was obviously very tongue in cheek, but quite amusing and obsessive.
Posted: 29/12/2008 08:20

Talkback: Can cycle computers slow you down?

First Name:
Last Name:
Nickname:
Email:
Security Image:
Enter the code shown:

I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct: